New Study Reveals How Tanzanian Farmers Navigate Conflicting Sustainability Worlds

Saymore Ngonidzashe Kativu (Project B05 “Science Futures”) argues that smallholder farmers in Mbeya, Tanzania navigate conflicting market-based and eco-cultural ideas of sustainability by creating hybrid farming strategies and meanings. He shows how these farmers reconcile competing knowledge systems—often emotionally and cognitively—revealing sustainability as a plural, negotiated, and context-specific process rather than a universal model.



Standing on shifting ground: Epistemological contradictions between markets and eco-cultural values of sustainability in smallholder farming in Mbeya, Tanzania

By Saymore Ngonidzashe Kativu (Project B05 “Science Futures”).

Abstract
This research explores how epistemological dissonance shapes agrarian sustainabilities in Mbeya, Tanzania. Through a case study of smallholder farmers navigating both market-driven and eco-cultural paradigms of sustainability, the research explores how plural epistemologies shape local sensemaking and agricultural decision-making. It demonstrates how farmers reconcile divergent sustainability logics, those rooted in market interpretations of sustainability with those rooted in relational ethics, ecological stewardship, and cultural continuity within agrarian landscapes. Employing hybrid strategies, farmers compartmentalize production, input intensive, market-targeting monocultures co-exist alongside primarily subsistence agroecological systems. These spatial divisions mirror deeper ontological tensions, as farmers articulate pride in market breakthroughs while expressing anxiety about environmental degradation, cultural erosion, and the loss of intergenerational practices. Building on plural sustainabilities literature and epistemologies of the South theories, the paper adds to scholarship reinterpreting sustainability not as a universal, singular paradigm, but a contested, contextually negotiated process. The case of Mbeya illustrates how epistemological dissonance becomes embodied through emotional and cognitive labor, and how hybrid sensemaking enables farmers to navigate conflicting knowledge systems. Rather than viewing hybridity as incoherence, the paper interprets these strategies as acts of situated resilience, adaptation, and resistance. The analysis contributes to political ecology and sustainability studies by foregrounding the ontological multiplicity at play in agrarian transitions and calls for institutional recognition of knowledge pluralism. Ultimately, the paper proposes a shift toward pluriversal sustainability frameworks that integrate both empirical and relational epistemologies, acknowledging that sustainable futures are as much about values and worldviews as they are about technologies and yields.



Reference

Kativu, S., N., Standing on shifting ground: Epistemological contradictions between markets and eco-cultural values of sustainability in smallholder farming in Mbeya, Tanzania, Current Research in Environmental Sustainability, Volume 10, 2025, 100322, DOI


More CRC News

traffic in kenya

The Economic Effects of Road Infrastructure in Kenya

This study, conducted by researchers from our sub-project A05 “Future Roads”, examines how improved road infrastructure affects local economic development in Kenya. Using data from ...
Read More »
cover for a web post

Hilman Fathoni Gives Keynote Speech on “Just Energy Transition in Indonesia and Germany”

November 11th, 2026 I 18:00 (CET), Berlin “People Power: The Energy Transition from the Ground Up – Examples from Germany and Indonesia”, organised by Watch ...
Read More »
cover for a website post

Universität zu Köln Mental Health Days

Die Mental Health Days bieten verschiedene Veranstaltungen und Angebote zu den Themen mentale Gesundheit und Wohlbefinden. Beschäftigte der Universität zu Köln können im Rahmen ihrer ...
Read More »
Stakeholders from Sosian Energy and GDC showing researchers aroundthe project sites

Project C02 “Energy Futures” Kicks off Phase III with a Travelling Workshop Through Kenya

By Katharina Oemmelen, Project C02 “Energy Futures” October 2026 To mark the start of CRC’s third phase, the C02 “Energy Futures” working group, made up ...
Read More »
cover for a web post

Financial Support for Master’s Theses on Convivial Conservation

The Convivial Conservation Centre aims to support two Msc/MA students in their thesis work on convivial conservation. Per student, funding of up to €1000 is ...
Read More »
Scroll to Top