Temporalizing modern planning

In the introduction to their edited volume Elusive Promises: Planning in the Contemporary World, Simone Abram and Gisa Weszkalnys (2013) introduce their understanding of modern planning as “an assemblage of activities, instruments, ideologies, models, and regulations aimed at ordering society through a set of social and spatial techniques” (ibid: 3). This open definition is in line with earlier works that discuss the relationship between planning and governmentality that focuses on subtle (and blatant) forms of power and control, such as James Scott’s Seeing Like a State (1998) and others, to which they refer briefly. The main conceptual contribution of Abram and Weszkalnys, however, is their call for a stronger temporalization of planning, hence demanding a shift of focus from the spatial domain of planning to the temporal domain. Whereas Scott and others show how states employ techniques of planning to ultimately make their populations legible by ordering space, Abram and Weszkalnys emphasize the effect of planning for the experience of temporality of the subjects that are confronted with plans from governmental actors. As a first step, Abram and Weszkalnys propose to understand planning as practices that manage the present by tying it to the future (2013: 11). Hence, practices of planning are a particular kind of future-making. Further, they understand planning as promise-making. Promises tie promisors (states) and promisees (citizens) together and promises are made in specific contexts. Unfulfilled promises harm the relationship between promisors and promisees and elusive promises make promisees stuck in a state of not- quite- yet or, as Abram and Weszkalnys frame it, in a state where the goals remain always “slightly out of reach” (ibid: 3).

As the CRC is concerned with large-scale plans and visions such as KAZA, LAPSET, or different national visions for 2030, Abram’s and Weszkalnys’ edited volume promises, and I think it does so without being elusive, to be of help for conceptualizing experiences of being stuck in the not- quite- yet. Such experiences were common at least for my interlocutors in Namibia’s Zambezi region. Though I hoped for a bit more conceptual ‘flesh’ about how to temporalize planning, the purpose of an introduction for an edited volume is not to preempt all conceptual work; it is rather to prepare the conceptual ground for empirical examples that demonstrate the diversity of how different practices that (promise) to prepare the future from the toolbox of modern bureaucratic statecraft shape citizen’s senses of temporal entanglement with the world. As such, the introduction certainly succeeded, and I look forward to reading the contributions to the volume.

By: Joachim Knab. Institute for African Studies, University of Cologne.

References

Abram, Simone & Gisa Weszkalnys (eds). 2013. Elusive Promises: Planning in the Contemporary World. New York: Berghahn.

Scott, James C. 1998. Seeing like a State: How Certain Schemes to Improve the Human Condition have Failed. New Haven, London: Yale University Press.

More CRC News

traffic in kenya

The Economic Effects of Road Infrastructure in Kenya

This study, conducted by researchers from our sub-project A05 “Future Roads”, examines how improved road infrastructure affects local economic development in Kenya. Using data from ...
Read More »
cover for a web post

Hilman Fathoni Gives Keynote Speech on “Just Energy Transition in Indonesia and Germany”

November 11th, 2026 I 18:00 (CET), Berlin “People Power: The Energy Transition from the Ground Up – Examples from Germany and Indonesia”, organised by Watch ...
Read More »
cover for a website post

Universität zu Köln Mental Health Days

Die Mental Health Days bieten verschiedene Veranstaltungen und Angebote zu den Themen mentale Gesundheit und Wohlbefinden. Beschäftigte der Universität zu Köln können im Rahmen ihrer ...
Read More »
Stakeholders from Sosian Energy and GDC showing researchers aroundthe project sites

Project C02 “Energy Futures” Kicks off Phase III with a Travelling Workshop Through Kenya

By Katharina Oemmelen, Project C02 “Energy Futures” October 2026 To mark the start of CRC’s third phase, the C02 “Energy Futures” working group, made up ...
Read More »
cover for a web post

Financial Support for Master’s Theses on Convivial Conservation

The Convivial Conservation Centre aims to support two Msc/MA students in their thesis work on convivial conservation. Per student, funding of up to €1000 is ...
Read More »
Scroll to Top