Publication: Power of Dissonance: Travelling Ideas & Local Realities – Community Conservation in Namibia’s Zambezi Region

Abstract

Environmental conservation is presented as a success story in Namibia’s Zambezi Region where conservation measures have led to an enormous increase in many wildlife populations. Complementary to historically exclusive fortress-conservation strategies, inclusive projects have gained prominence in the past few decades aiming to integrate local populations into conservation projects. Perhaps the most salient approach is community-based natural resource management (CBNRM), which sets ambitious goals of more participation, empowerment, and stewardship of local residents in the process of conservation. Despite its popularity in southern Africa, the CBNRM concept has met with criticism, especially with regard to the situations of many conservancy members. We aim to show that the idea of conservation, and the concept of CBNRM in particular, are in some respects detached from the lives of the conservancy members who are confronted with the effects and regulations of conservation measures. We therefore employ the notion of ‘dissonance’ to describe the inconsistencies between the intended effects of the CBNRM concept and how it is perceived by conservancy members. Three aspects of dissonance are identified here. First, we draw attention to the limited opportunities conservancy members have to benefit from the thriving safari- and hunting-tourism industry. Second, despite successful conservation leading to increased wildlife populations, impacts of human-wildlife conflicts (HWC) and their repercussions for farming and livestock husbandry aggravate the dissonant relationship between conservancy members and the CBNRM concept. Third, we illustrate the discrepancies between the notion of the ‘community’ in conservancies and the actual social organisation. Altogether, the inconsistencies between the travelling idea of conservation and its impact on local livelihoods will be demonstrated.

Vehrs, HP, Kalvelage, L, Nghitevelekwa, R [Epub ahead of print], ‘The Power of Dissonance: Inconsistent Relations Between Travelling Ideas And Local Realities in Community Conservation in Namibia’s Zambezi Region‘, Conservation & Society, Link to preprint.

More CRC News

geothermal energy plant in Kenya

New Publication: The Unintended Socio-Economic Transformations of Kenya’s Green Energy Boom

In this new publication, Clemens Greiner, Britta Klagge, Samuel Owuor (Project C02 Energy Futures) alognside Cynthia Wamukota and Isaiah Nyandega examine the unintended socio-economic impacts of ...
Read More »
Group photo with the minister, Deputy Minsiter, Parmanent Secretary, the Board members

Professor Theobald Frank Theodory Appointed to NEMC Board of Directors

We are proud to share that Professor Dr. Theobald Frank Theodory of Mzumbe University, Tanzania, and cooperation partner of Project C03 Green Futures, has been ...
Read More »
image of an african savannah

New Publication: How Land-Use Change Shapes Carbon Storage in African Savannas

In this article, Liana Kindermann, Alexandra Sandhage-Hofmann, Wulf Amelung, Jan Börner, J., Ezequiel Fabiano, Maximilian Meyer and Anja Linstädter (Project A01 Future Carbon Storage) and ...
Read More »
photo of a train station in kenya

New Publication: Kenya’s SGR Fuels Land Inequality. How Different Land Tenure Systems Offer Varying Degrees of Protection and Vulnerability

Kennedy Mkutu, Evelyn Owino and Conrad Schetter from sub-project B03 Violent Futures and Tessa Mkutu examine how Kenya’s Nairobi–Mombasa Standard Gauge Railway (SGR) has affected ...
Read More »
poster for a public lecture with kai koddenbrock

CRC-TRR Public Lecture: Kai Koddenbrock

Mon | May 5th, 2025 | 16:00 – 17:30  (CEST) Earnest Struggles for Structural Transformation in West Africa: Governing the Disarticulated Economy Since Independence Prof. ...
Read More »
Scroll to Top